This is a body count for the My Super Psycho Sweet 16 series.
My Super Psycho Sweet 16
| # | Name | Death | Killer | Location |
| 1 | Karen | Unknown | Charlie Rotter | Roller-Dome (Skating Floor) |
| 2 | Craig | Pool stick driven thorugh back of head and out of mouth. | Charlie Rotter | Roller-Dome (Skating Floor) |
| 3 | Party Planner | Disemboweled with a sharp pole. | Charlie Rotter | Roller-Dome (Backstage) |
| 4 | Kevin Donaldson | Strangled and beat with a mace-like weapon. | Charlie Rotter | Roller-Dome (Mezzanine) |
| 5 | Chloe Anderson | Beat with a fire extinguisher. | Charlie Rotter |
Roller-Dome (Bathroom) |
| 6 | Lily McFadden | Throat slit with a sword. | Charlie Rotter | Roller-Dome (Alley) |
| 7 | Olivia Wade | Decapitated with an axe. | Charlie Rotter | Roller-Dome (Skating Floor) |
| 8 | Madison Penrose | Throat slit with a knife. | Charlie Rotter | Roller-Dome (Basement) |
Karen's Corpse
Craig's Death
Party Planner's Corpse
Kevin's End
Chloe's Body
Lily Moments Before Demise
Olivia's Headless Skate
"Have a Super Birthday Madison"
My Super Psycho Sweet 16 Part 2
| # | Name | Death | Killer | Location |
| 1 | Ted Bell | Stabbed numerous times and decapitated. | Charlie Rotter | Bone Yard (Parking Lot) |
| 2 | Molly Abiko | Stabbed through head with electric knife. | Charlie Rotter | Bone Yard (Kitchen) |
| 3 | James Feldman | Continuously hacked with a meat cleaver. | Charlie Rotter | Bone Yard (Kitchen) |
| 4 | Derek McNamera | Neck impaled with a nail in a board. | Charlie Rotter | Bone Yard (Alley) |
| 5 | Courtney Ramirez | Face smashed in with meat tenderizer. | Charlie Rotter | Bone Yard (Kitchen) |
| 6 | Zoe Chandler | Accidently catches herself on fire when lighting a match not knowing she is covered in alcohol. | Charlie Rotter | Bone Yard (Club/ParkingLot) |
| 7 | Carolyn Bell | Throat slit with knife. | Charlie Rotter | Bone Yard (Upper Level) |
| 8 | Charlie Rotter | Stabbed through heart. | Skye Rotter | Bone Yard (Upper Level) |
Ted's Head
Molly's Demise
Jams' Corpse
Derek's Death
Courtney's End
Zoe's Body
Carolyn's Death
Skye, killing her father
My Super Psycho Sweet 16: Part 3
| # | Name | Death | Killer | Location |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1/2 | Alex's Grandfather | Unknown | Alex or Nathan | Bell Manor |
| 1/2 | Alex's Grandmother | Unknown | Alex or Nathan | Bell Manor |
| 3 | Brynn | Beat in the head with lamp post. | Nathan Stillo | Bell Manor (Pool Deck) |
| 4 | Ami | Impaled with nails from a nail gun. | Nathan Stillo | Bell Manor (Hallway) |
| 5 | Leo | Throat slit with a knife. | Alex Bell | Bell Manor (Balcony) |
| 6 | Nico | Stabbed and hit on the head with a crowbar. | Nathan Stillo | Bell Manor (Back Yard) |
| 7 | Nathan Stillo | Disemboweled with scythe. | Alex Bell | Bell Manor (Dining Room) |
Skye Rotter, Alex Bell and Sienna survive.
- However Alex is arrested and put in an insane asylum.
- Brigg also survives but he did not attend the party.
Brynn's Death
Ami shot with the nail gun.
Leo's Demise
Nico barely alive.
Nathan's End
